Short answerThis scorecard puts public data from state contractor records, manufacturer directories, Google, Yelp, BBB and each company's own website into one clean format. RoofSmart is one of the 14 companies scored. We chose the scoring rules, published them below, and applied them the same way to every company. The 60 points shown are the ones anyone can check; the other 40 can only be judged from a bid.See exactly how each score was calculatedHow to judge the other 40 points in your own bid
You deserve to find the roofing company that will work best for your needs. Even if that means not choosing to work with us.
Profiles follow the score order from the results table below.
| Rank, company, score and reviews |
|---|
|
1. RoofSmart (Kent)
48/60Reviews 8 of 8Google 4.87Yelp 5.00Blend 4.93
|
|
2. Patriot Roofing (Gig Harbor)
39/60Reviews 0 of 8Google 4.56Yelp 3.00Blend 3.78
|
|
3. Hanley Construction / Hanley Roofing (Port Orchard)
33/60Reviews 8 of 8Google 4.94Yelp noneBlend 4.94 (Google only)
|
|
4. NearMe Roofing Company (Redmond)⚑ Bond suit
30/60Reviews 6 of 8Google 4.58Yelp 5.00Blend 4.79
|
|
5. IBEX Roof (Fircrest / Tacoma)
27/60Reviews 8 of 8Google 4.95Yelp noneBlend 4.95 (Google only)
|
|
6. Guardian Roofing, Gutters & Insulation (Auburn)
24/60Reviews 0 of 8Google 4.81Yelp 3.00Blend 3.90
|
|
7. Polar Bear Exterior Solutions (Mukilteo)
23/60Reviews 6 of 8Google 4.57Yelp 5.00Blend 4.79
|
|
8. Pro Roofing NW (Kirkland)
21/60Reviews 4 of 8Google 4.57Yelp noneBlend 4.57 (Google only)
|
|
9. High Performance Homes (Auburn office; HQ Vancouver)⚑ Bond suit
19/60Reviews 8 of 8Google 4.86Yelp noneBlend 4.86 (Google only)
|
|
10. State Roofing & Exteriors (Marysville / Tacoma)⚑ Bond suit
15/60Reviews 0 of 8Google 4.39Yelp 2.25Blend 3.32
|
|
11. Valentine Roofing (Tukwila)⚑ Bond suit
12/60Reviews 0 of 8Google 4.77Yelp 2.36Blend 3.57
|
|
12. TriState Roofing (Tacoma)⚑ Bond suit
10/60Reviews 0 of 8Google 4.20Yelp 1.00Blend 2.60
|
|
13. Erie Home (Erie Construction Mid-West LLC)⚑ Bond suit
9/60Reviews 4 of 8Google 4.47Yelp noneBlend 4.47 (Google only)
|
|
14. DaBella (Federal Way / Seattle office)⚑ Bond suit
5/60Reviews 0 of 8Google 4.41Yelp 1.58Blend 3.00
|
⚑ Bond suit = active bond lawsuit on file with L&I (an allegation, not a finding)8, 9; tap the ⚑ in a table for the case details.
Numbered notes are at the end of this article.
This scorecard covers 14 residential roofers serving the Seattle metro, RoofSmart included. Every number comes from public records and each company's own website, listed below the company cards, and one written rule set was applied to every company.
Each company first had to pass an entry check: an active Washington L&I contractor license with a bond and liability insurance on file.
What we screen for firstDedication to installation quality, strong reviews and a long track record. Ten-plus years is a strong signal, but the hard entry gate is an active Washington L&I registration with insurance.Every company gets the same nine checks and the same BBB deduction. The weights add up to 100; the BBB deduction comes off the score out of 60.
| Check | Points |
|---|---|
| L&I record | 15 |
| Three parts from the state contractor record, below. Without a clean license nothing else matters. | |
| Safety | 10 of 15 |
| Inspections with citations in the last 5 years (since Oct 14, 2021), divided by 5, or by years licensed if licensed under 5 years. None: 10. Up to 0.25 a year: 8. Over 0.25 to 0.5: 6. Over 0.5 to 1.0: 3. Over 1.0: 0, plus a safety flag. | |
| License type | 1 of 15 |
| General contractor: 1. Specialty license: 0. | |
| Strikes, bond lawsuits and lapses | 4 of 15 |
| Clean record: 4. One open bond lawsuit, or 2 or more lapses since Oct 14, 2021: 2. Two open bond lawsuits, or one plus 2 or more lapses: 1. Any strike or debarment: 0. A lapse counts only if it lasted more than a month, from the lapse date to the reinstatement date; lapses resolved within a month are not counted. Only open bond lawsuits count. We also check the older or linked licenses the state contractor lookup lists for each company for open bond lawsuits, where it shows detail. | |
| Years in business | 5 |
| Many new businesses do not last, so a longer licensed record counts. Counted from the earliest linked L&I license. Under 5 years: 0. 5 to under 10: 2. 10 to under 15: 4. 15 or more: 5. | |
| In-house crews | 10 |
| Crews on the payroll are easier to hold to one standard than rotating subcontractors. | |
| Manufacturer tier | 15 |
| We treat three manufacturer programs as equivalent top tiers: GAF Golden Pledge / Master Elite, CertainTeed ShingleMaster PREMIER and Owens Corning Platinum Preferred. Each one confirmed in the manufacturer's own contractor directory earns 5 points, so one program is 5, two are 10 and all three are 15. A company with no top program gets 5 for a mid tier (CertainTeed SELECT, Owens Corning Preferred or GAF Certified Plus) or 2 for an entry tier (CertainTeed ShingleMaster or GAF Certified). A tier claimed on a company's website but not found in the directory earns nothing and is flagged. | |
| Written scope (bid only) | 15 |
| A clear written scope is what lets you compare bids fairly. | |
| Tailored Solution for Me (bid only) | 10 |
| Does the plan answer your roof's specific problems and your goals? The test: it's either in your bid, or it's boilerplate. | |
| Warranty honesty | 7 |
| Does the warranty say plainly what is and isn't covered? | |
| Reviews | 8 |
| We show each company's average Google rating and average Yelp rating for reviews posted in the 12 months ending Oct 14, 2026. If a company has more than one Google or Yelp listing in our market (King, Pierce, Thurston and Kitsap counties and south Snohomish County), we pool the reviews from all of them. The score uses the simple average of those two figures, so Google and Yelp count equally. If a company has no Yelp (or no Google) reviews in that window, we use the other platform alone. If neither platform can be verified, the line scores 0. A company needs at least 10 reviews in the window across both platforms to earn points. Fewer than 10 gets a "too few recent reviews" flag, with the averages still shown. Blended 4.8 or higher: 8. 4.6 to under 4.8: 6. 4.4 to under 4.6: 4. 4.0 to under 4.4: 2. Under 4.0: 0. Scored on the unrounded average. We weight Google and Yelp equally because Yelp is where unhappy customers tend to post, so it shows a side Google can hide. | |
| Cost and value (bid only) | 15 |
| What you get for the money, not the lowest bid. | |
| Total | 100 |
Written scope, Tailored Solution for Me, and cost and value (40 points) can only be judged from a bid, so ask for them in yours.2
Each L&I count is the number of inspections that ended with citations, however many violation lines an inspection lists, and it is counted the same way for all 14 companies. Inspections under appeal are included in the count.
BBB complaints: BBB shows the last three years, so this rule applies to that window only. A company with more than 3 BBB complaints in the last three years, which is more than one a year, loses 5 points from its score out of 60. A company with 3 or fewer loses nothing, so a clean record costs nothing. We read each company's BBB profile on October 23, 2026. BBB reports the counts and we did not check them. For Erie Home and DaBella, BBB's counts are nationwide totals. The note under the BBB table gives the average per state.
A low score means the company doesn't show that publicly, not that it doesn't do it.
Years in business counts because many new businesses do not last.
Of private establishments opened in the year to March 2020, 49% nationally and 58% in Washington were gone by March 2025 (BLS).1
Each card adds up to the total out of 60, after any BBB deduction.
Inspections with citations, including any under appeal, are counted from Oct 14, 2021 to Oct 14, 2026. Each inspection counts once, however many violation lines it lists. Lapses are counted since October 2021, and only a lapse that lasted more than a month counts.
| 1. RoofSmart (Kent) 48/60 | |
| L&I 8 of 15 | 3 inspections with citations, 0.60 a year. No strikes, no open bond suits, 1 lapse, none over a month. See note 15. |
| Mfr 10 of 15 | CertainTeed ShingleMaster PREMIER, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred |
| Reviews 8 of 8 | Google 4.87, Yelp 5.00, blended 4.93 |
| Years 5 of 5. In-house crews 10 of 10. Warranty 7 of 7. | |
| Flags | Small Yelp sample |
| 2. Patriot Roofing (Gig Harbor) 39/60 | |
| L&I 11 of 15 | 2 inspections with citations, 0.40 a year. No strikes, no open bond suits, no lapses over a month. |
| Mfr 10 of 15 | CertainTeed ShingleMaster PREMIER, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred |
| Reviews 0 of 8 | Google 4.56, Yelp 3.00, blended 3.78 |
| Years 4 of 5. In-house crews 10 of 10. Warranty 4 of 7. | |
| 3. Hanley Construction / Hanley Roofing (Port Orchard) 33/60 | |
| L&I 11 of 15 | 2 inspections with citations, 0.40 a year. No strikes, no open bond suits, 0 lapses. |
| Mfr 5 of 15 | CertainTeed ShingleMaster PREMIER |
| Reviews 8 of 8 | Google 4.94, Yelp none in window, blended 4.94 (Google alone) |
| Years 5 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 4 of 7. | |
| 4. NearMe Roofing Company (Redmond) 30/60 ⚑ Bond suit | |
| L&I 13 of 15 | 0 inspections with citations, 0.00 a year. No strikes, 1 open bond suit, no lapses over a month. |
| Mfr 5 of 15 | GAF Master Elite / Golden Pledge |
| Reviews 6 of 8 | Google 4.58, Yelp 5.00, blended 4.79 |
| Years 2 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 4 of 7. | |
| Flags | Small workforce band; small Yelp sample |
| 5. IBEX Roof (Fircrest / Tacoma) 27/60 | |
| L&I 11 of 15 | 2 inspections with citations, 0.40 a year. No strikes, no open bond suits, 0 lapses. |
| Mfr 0 of 15 | none confirmed |
| Reviews 8 of 8 | Google 4.95, Yelp none in window, blended 4.95 (Google alone) |
| Years 4 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 4 of 7. | |
| Flags | Tier claim not in directory |
| 6. Guardian Roofing, Gutters & Insulation (Auburn) 24/60 | |
| L&I 5 of 15 | 6 inspections with citations, 1.20 a year, safety flag. No strikes, no open bond suits, 0 lapses. |
| Mfr 10 of 15 | GAF Master Elite / Golden Pledge, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred |
| Reviews 0 of 8 | Google 4.81, Yelp 3.00, blended 3.90 |
| Years 5 of 5. In-house crews 5 of 10. Warranty 4 of 7. | |
| Crews: Guardian's site says its in-house teams handle gutter, insulation and attic ventilation work. We found no line saying its own crews do the roof installs, so we score it as a mix of its own crews and others: 5 of 10. | |
| BBB: minus 5 (7 complaints in the last 3 years). Total 24/60. | |
| Flags | Safety >1/yr (5 yr) |
| 7. Polar Bear Exterior Solutions (Mukilteo) 23/60 | |
| L&I 13 of 15 | 1 inspection with citations, 0.20 a year. No strikes, no open bond suits, 0 lapses. |
| Mfr 0 of 15 | none confirmed |
| Reviews 6 of 8 | Google 4.57, Yelp 5.00, blended 4.79 |
| Years 4 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 0 of 7. | |
| Flags | Tier claim not in directory; uses subs (per L&I citation, note 13); small Yelp sample |
| 8. Pro Roofing NW (Kirkland) 21/60 | |
| L&I 8 of 15 | 4 inspections with citations, 0.80 a year. No strikes, no open bond suits, 3 lapses, 1 over a month. |
| Mfr 5 of 15 | GAF Master Elite / Golden Pledge |
| Reviews 4 of 8 | Google 4.57, Yelp none in window, blended 4.57 (Google alone) |
| Years 5 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 4 of 7. | |
| BBB: minus 5 (4 complaints in the last 3 years). Total 21/60. | |
| Flags | Small workforce band; uses subs (per L&I citation, note 11) |
| 9. High Performance Homes (Auburn office; HQ Vancouver) 19/60 ⚑ Bond suit | |
| L&I 7 of 15 | 2 inspections with citations, 0.40 a year. 1 strike, 2 open bond suits, no lapses over a month. |
| Mfr 5 of 15 | Owens Corning Platinum Preferred |
| Reviews 8 of 8 | Google 4.86, Yelp none in window, blended 4.86 (Google alone) |
| Years 4 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 0 of 7. | |
| BBB: minus 5 (31 complaints in the last 3 years). Total 19/60. | |
| Flags | Strike; uses subs (per L&I citation, note 14) |
| 10. State Roofing & Exteriors (Marysville / Tacoma) 15/60 ⚑ Bond suit | |
| L&I 10 of 15 | 1 inspection with citations, 0.20 a year. No strikes, 2 open bond suits, 0 lapses. |
| Mfr 5 of 15 | GAF Master Elite / Golden Pledge |
| Reviews 0 of 8 | Google 4.39, Yelp 2.25, blended 3.32 (see note 30) |
| Years 5 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 0 of 7. | |
| BBB: minus 5 (8 complaints in the last 3 years). Total 15/60. | |
| Flags | Tier claims not in directory; small Yelp sample |
| 11. Valentine Roofing (Tukwila) 12/60 ⚑ Bond suit | |
| L&I 3 of 15 | 14 inspections with citations, 2.80 a year, safety flag. No strikes, 1 open bond suit, no lapses over a month. |
| Mfr 5 of 15 | Owens Corning Platinum Preferred |
| Reviews 0 of 8 | Google 4.77, Yelp 2.36, blended 3.57 |
| Years 5 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 4 of 7. | |
| BBB: minus 5 (6 complaints in the last 3 years). Total 12/60. | |
| Flags | Safety >1/yr (5 yr) |
| 12. TriState Roofing (Tacoma) 10/60 ⚑ Bond suit | |
| L&I 5 of 15 | 5 inspections with citations, 1.00 a year. No strikes, 2 open bond suits, no lapses over a month. |
| Mfr 5 of 15 | GAF Master Elite / Golden Pledge |
| Reviews 0 of 8 | Google 4.20, Yelp 1.00, blended 2.60 |
| Years 5 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 0 of 7. | |
| BBB: minus 5 (7 complaints in the last 3 years). Total 10/60. | |
| Flags | Tier claim not in directory; small Yelp sample |
| 13. Erie Home (Erie Construction Mid-West LLC) 9/60 ⚑ Bond suit | |
| L&I 6 of 15 | 2 inspections with citations, 0.51 a year over 3.9 years licensed. No strikes, 1 open bond suit, 5 lapses, 1 over a month. |
| Mfr 0 of 15 | none confirmed |
| Reviews 4 of 8 | Google 4.47, Yelp none in window, blended 4.47 (Google alone) |
| Years 0 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 4 of 7. | |
| BBB: minus 5 (443 complaints in the last 3 years33). Total 9/60. | |
| Flags | Small workforce band; licensed under 5 yrs; uses subs (per L&I citation, note 10) |
| 14. DaBella (Federal Way / Seattle office) 5/60 ⚑ Bond suit | |
| L&I 1 of 15 | 12 inspections with citations, 2.40 a year, safety flag. 2 strikes, 2 open bond suits, lapses not listed. |
| Mfr 5 of 15 | GAF Master Elite / Golden Pledge |
| Reviews 0 of 8 | Google 4.41, Yelp 1.58, blended 3.00 |
| Years 4 of 5. In-house crews 0 of 10. Warranty 0 of 7. | |
| BBB: minus 5 (586 complaints in the last 3 years33). Total 5/60. | |
| Flags | Safety >1/yr (5 yr); strikes; uses subs (per L&I citation, note 12) |
Points and deductions came only from public records and each company's own website, checked on Oct 14, 2026 except BBB and the linked-license check, which were checked on October 23, 2026, and Patriot's and State's Google and Yelp reviews, re-read on November 18, 2026 for the same 12-month window:
| Source | What it gave us |
|---|---|
| WA L&I contractor lookup | Safety (inspections with citations), license type, years licensed (including linked predecessor licenses), strikes, bond suits, lapses and workers' comp workforce size |
| GAF, CertainTeed and Owens Corning directories | Manufacturer tier |
| Google and Yelp | Reviews from the last 12 months (window ends 10/14/2026) |
| Each company's own website | Crew model and warranty terms |
| BBB | Rating and complaint counts for the last 3 years |
L&I records we used for each company (checked Oct 14, 2026):
RoofSmart Patriot Roofing Guardian Roofing, Gutters & Insulation Hanley Construction / Hanley Roofing NearMe Roofing Company State Roofing & Exteriors Valentine Roofing Pro Roofing NW High Performance Homes IBEX Roof TriState Roofing DaBella Polar Bear Exterior Solutions Erie Home
BBB data is reported by BBB and not checked by us. It affects a score only through the deduction described in How the scores work: more than 3 complaints in the last 3 years takes off 5 points. Counts were read on October 23, 2026. Complaint counts are worth a look before you sign.
| Company | BBB rating | Complaints, last 3 years | Score effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. RoofSmart (Kent) | A+ | None | none |
| 2. Patriot Roofing (Gig Harbor) | A+ | 1 | none |
| 3. Hanley Construction / Hanley Roofing (Port Orchard) | A+ | None | none |
| 4. NearMe Roofing Company (Redmond) | A+ | None | none |
| 5. IBEX Roof (Fircrest / Tacoma) | A+ | 3 | none |
| 6. Guardian Roofing, Gutters & Insulation (Auburn) | A+ | 7 | minus 5 |
| 7. Polar Bear Exterior Solutions (Mukilteo) | A+ | None | none |
| 8. Pro Roofing NW (Kirkland) | A+ | 4 | minus 5 |
| 9. High Performance Homes (Auburn office; HQ Vancouver) | A+ | 31 | minus 5 |
| 10. State Roofing & Exteriors (Marysville / Tacoma) | A+ | 8 | minus 5 |
| 11. Valentine Roofing (Tukwila) | A+ | 6 | minus 5 |
| 12. TriState Roofing (Tacoma) | A+ | 7 | minus 5 |
| 13. Erie Home (Erie Construction Mid-West LLC) | A+ | 443 33 | minus 5 |
| 14. DaBella (Federal Way / Seattle office) | A+ | 586 33 | minus 5 |
All 14 companies are BBB accredited and rated A+.
Book a SmartMatch Needs Analysis
The scorecard covers the 60 points anyone can check.
The other 40 can only be judged from a bid or a meeting, so every company here scored 0 on them.
Here is how to score them yourself, one criterion at a time.
A clear written scope is what lets you compare bids fairly.
Ask in your bid or meeting
Red flags
Our guides and videos
Read: How to compare roofing proposals
Does the plan answer your roof's specific problems and your goals? The test: it's either in your bid, or it's boilerplate.
Ask in your bid or meeting
Red flags
Our guides and videos
Cost and value is scored on what the price buys: scope, materials, crew and warranty for the money.
A low number that leaves out ventilation or flashing scores lower than a fair price for the full job.
Ask in your bid or meeting
Red flags
Our guides and videos
RoofSmart's Seattle proposals put the median asphalt shingle replacement at about $9.42 per sq ft plus tax, or about $23,500 for a 2,500 sq ft roof, before add-ons.
RoofSmart's own Seattle rate is $10.59 per sq ft plus tax.
For add-ons, flat roofs and how RoofSmart prices, see our Seattle roof replacement cost page.
We invite you to research us as well and compare us to the other companies in the scorecard.
Give us a call at (206) 487-4877 or fill out this short form to contact us and get started today.
That is the promise of a SmartMatch Needs Analysis (when there is no active leak): a plain-English findings sheet, and if you don't need a new roof, we say so.
Book a SmartMatch Needs Analysis
Notes and sources (scroll inside this box)