Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

Difference Between Roof Warranties

6 min read

By Jim Singleterry

Frustrated homeowner on the phone at her kitchen table with a stack of roof warranty paperwork.
Everything You Need To Know About Roofing Warranties
11:37

A new roof is a big investment for a Greater Seattle homeowner, so the warranty should be part of the decision. A lifetime warranty can mean very different things once you read the fine print. Some pay labor only to repair, replace or recover the maker's own defective material. Installation mistakes may not be covered either, unless you know what to look for. It's worth knowing the main types of coverage before you sign. Here is how those types work, and what they leave out.

Quick Answers

Not all roofing warranties are created equal.

Most standard warranties cover material defects, and the maker pays labor only to repair, replace or recover its own defective material, while workmanship warranties cover installation errors but are limited by the contractor’s reliability. For maximum protection, homeowners should look for Extended/Enhanced Warranties from certified contractors that cover both materials and labor. RoofSmart differentiates itself in the Seattle market by offering a TripleGuard Warranty, providing lifetime workmanship and lifetime material coverage on eligible roofs, plus a promise the work meets code. 

Roofing Warranties: What’s Covered? How Do They Work?

A roof replacement is a pretty serious investment for the average Greater Seattle Area homeowner. Regardless of which one of the many material options you choose, you’ll want to make sure you protect your new roof with the best roofing warranty available to you.

While you might be offered a "lifetime warranty," if you don’t read over the fine print, you may find out when it’s too late that a standard material warranty pays labor only to repair, replace or recover the maker’s own defective material. And don’t forget mistakes! You expect those to be covered too, right? It’s important to know the major types of warranties that are out there so that you are better informed when it’s time to have your roof replaced.


Types Of Roofing Warranties

Three main types of roofing warranties offer different benefits and coverage options. You’ll need to read over your warranty carefully to understand exactly what’s covered with your roof replacement.


Material Defect-Only Warranty

A material defect-only warranty is a manufacturer’s warranty that covers manufacturing defects in the materials. It protects you as the homeowner from faulty materials. The material is typically covered for its expected lifespan.

This type of warranty covers a manufacturing defect only. During its early TRU PROtection period, the Owens Corning Standard Product Limited Warranty pays labor only to repair, replace or recover the maker’s own defective material. It does not pay for tear-off, disposal, flashings, vents or other components, or for installation workmanship. After that period, coverage is prorated, for materials only, with no labor. The homeowner pays the rest. And, again, ONLY if there’s a defect. Not “worn out.” Big difference!

It is also understood industry-wide that this type of warranty will not cover shingles that are damaged due to faulty installation or any other issues that arose when your roof was installed.

Page 1 of the Owens Corning Standard Product Limited Lifetime Warranty on Roofing Shingles and Components, including the What Is Covered section.
The Owens Corning Standard Product Limited Lifetime Warranty, a material defect-only warranty. Source: Owens Corning.

Comprehensive Warranty With Labor

Leading manufacturers like Owens Corning and CertainTeed offer comprehensive warranties with labor included, if there’s a defect. These warranties typically require that the entire roof be replaced for customers to qualify for the warranty, not just a partial. Additionally, the roof must be installed by a qualified contractor who is certified to install their products.

Most of these warranties offer a range of benefits. All roof system components will be covered except flashing, fasteners, and wood decking. They will offer coverage for defective materials that is extended, non-prorated, or continuous and typically includes the cost of repairs or replacements.

Additionally, you’ll be protected against installation errors in the roof system with some level of workmanship coverage. It may be a lifetime term that begins prorating after a certain number of years, and it will include labor, removal, and disposal costs.

Page 1 of the Owens Corning Platinum Protection Limited Lifetime Warranty, including the What Is Covered and Workmanship Terms sections.
The Owens Corning Platinum Protection Limited Lifetime Warranty, a comprehensive warranty with labor. Source: Owens Corning.

Workmanship Warranty

Workmanship warranties are offered by home contractors who complete the roof replacements. Because every company is different, not every workmanship warranty is created equal. One major difference can be the length of coverage offered between contractors; however, some may offer lifetime warranties.

While it’s usually true that a longer coverage period is better, the warranty you are being offered should cover you against material failures that arise from installation mistakes or worker errors, no matter what the coverage term is.

This type of warranty typically covers labor and materials needed for the repairs. Many also cover the damage costs for your furniture and personal belongings when the mistake causes interior destruction.

Workmanship warranties, however, usually do not include issues that are not related to installation problems such as storm damage, water damage due to ice dams, damage due to roof alterations following installation, foot traffic, or fallen tree limbs.

RoofSmart offers the only Lifetime Workmanship Warranty in the Seattle area for qualifying designs. We stand behind our installations 100%.

The RoofSmart Lifetime Roofing Warranty document, with workmanship coverage terms, exclusions, and a blank customer form.
The RoofSmart Lifetime Roofing Warranty, the workmanship part of TripleGuard. Source: RoofSmart.

How the Three Warranty Types Compare

Warranty Comparison Matrix
Warranty Type What It Covers How It Works / Duration Claim Process Limitations / Exclusions Consumer Tips
Manufacturer's Warranty Defects in the roofing materials (e.g., shingles cracking due to manufacturing flaws). Provided by the material maker; can be a lifetime term for premium products, prorated after initial period. Contact manufacturer with proof of purchase, installation details, and evidence of defect; they may inspect and provide replacement materials. Labor only to repair, replace or recover its own defective material. Never tear-off, disposal, flashings, vents, other parts or install. Always register the warranty if required; keep receipts and photos; choose reputable brands like CertainTeed or GAF for better terms.
Workmanship Warranty Errors in installation by the contractor (e.g., improper nailing, flashing, or ventilation leading to leaks). Offered by the roofing contractor; length varies, and some certified installers offer longer terms. File claim with the contractor; they inspect and repair if valid. Excludes material defects, acts of God (e.g., storms), homeowner modifications, or lack of maintenance. May void if contractor goes out of business. Get it in writing with clear terms; hire licensed, insured contractors; consider extended options for longer protection.
Extended/Enhanced Warranty (e.g., System or Lifetime) Comprehensive coverage including both materials and workmanship, often non-prorated for full replacement value. Provided by manufacturer through certified contractors; can be lifetime, with options like no-dollar-limit guarantees. Handled by manufacturer or contractor; requires registration and periodic inspections. Higher upfront cost; exclusions for extreme weather, neglect, or non-approved repairs. May require specific materials and installers. Ideal for long-term homeowners; compare programs like GAF Golden Pledge or Owens Corning Platinum; factor in transferability for resale value.

Types Of Roofing Materials Available

Now that you know about the different kinds of roofing warranties that are out there, you can begin researching what kind of material you want to be installed on your new roof. There are several great options, including those for flat roofs.


Composition Roofing

Composition roofs are a combination of multiple materials instead of being made of just one single material. They’re typically made from a mixture of fiberglass, laminate, slate, and wood. The three main types of these roofs are 3 tab, laminated architectural, and Designer shingles.

They boast an impressive lifespan along with being very cost-effective, aesthetically pleasing, and customizable while offering easy replacement. This option typically comes with a material defect-only warranty but this is the category that's most competitive. So the shingle manufacturers started offering "extended warranties" about 20 years ago to differentiate and offer added value to homeowners like you. On paper, these are the best warranties. They offer a guarantee from not just the installer, but from the manufacturer itself that they will stand behind the workmanship of the project for properly qualified contractors. But standards have slipped.

It doesn't take much anymore to be a "qualified contractor" for these extended warranties. What they have are specific instructions to make the project eligible. Such as ventilation. When basics are neglected and you later file a claim...no coverage due to negligence. Choose your roofer wisely.

Seattle: Overhead view of a two-story house with a gray asphalt shingle roof and a small skylight, a white vehicle with its front doors open in the driveway, and raised garden beds beside the house.
A finished asphalt shingle roof on a two-story house, seen from above. Photo: RoofSmart.

Metal Roofing

You won't see an extended warranty on Metal roofs. Defect and Workmanship only.
In Seattle these are composed of metal pieces, tiles, or panels. They offer great benefits like longer lifespans, limited environmental impact, and increased energy efficiency. While the initial investment is typically more than that of an asphalt roof, the return on investment is greater when you consider how long the roof can last.

The materials used are lighter and are a true “green” roof. It’s 100% recyclable, perfect for solar installations. They can even be installed over the current shingle roof to save time and money on installation and removal fees (we rarely do this). Instead of a warranty on the actual materials, you’ll be provided with coverage on the paint that protects the metal roof. The metal itself doesn’t go bad, just the paint. Someday.

metal bad ridge
Old metal roof with SMP (inferior) finish

Shake Roofing

A cedar shake roof is made of premium cedar materials. Other than exceptional cases, the only warranty you get on cedar shake roof is workmanship from your installer (so choose very carefully). What makes it different from other roof types is it’s much more aesthetic. These shingles are made to order, not kept in a stockpile. The average lifespan of a shake roof varies greatly because of the grade of shakes and the quality of the installation, just like all other roof types. Higher quality wood and treatments make a huge difference.

Seattle: Aerial view of a small gray house with a cedar shake roof, a tall brick chimney, and a yellow autumn tree in the front yard.
A cedar shake roof on a small gray house, with a tall brick chimney. Photo: RoofSmart.

Flat Roofing Options

When you have a flat roof, your options change slightly. You won’t use any of the previously discussed options. Typical flat roofing options include TPO and PVC, or torchdown.

TPO or Thermoplastic Polyolefin is a single-ply membrane that is made of sheets of rubber or other synthetic materials and it is attached to the insulation of your commercial facility to create a layer of protection. This type of roof is reasonably durable and UV reflective.

PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride) roofing is also known as vinyl roofing. This type of roofing is heat-welded at the seams, one of the longest-lasting flat roofing options available, and UV reflective.

These roofing systems can come with a material defect-only warranty but there are extended warranties available. Some brands though, it's only for commercial projects and only with additional engineering. Not typically suitable for a homeowner's budget.

Workmanship is critical on these "rooftop bathtubs" because any small mistake WILL leak.

Duro-Last PVC flat roof on a Seattle home
A Duro-Last PVC flat roof with welded seams and flashings. Photo: RoofSmart.

Other Articles You’ll Find Interesting:

The Roof Replacement Timeline and What You Can Expect

How To Choose A Roofing Contractor

Why We Photo-Document Your Roof Replacement


 Scott's story is a case study. Don't pay twice like he did: 

Are You Ready To Replace Your Old Roof?

Choose The Company With The TripleGuard Warranty

If you’re ready to make the huge investment of a full roof replacement on your Greater Seattle Area home, you need a company that’s going to back up its work with the best warranty possible. Call the roofing experts at RoofSmart!

We offer a TripleGuard Warranty that provides lifetime workmanship and lifetime material coverage on eligible roofs, plus a promise the work meets code.

Call us today at (206) 487-4877 or schedule your free estimate. We look forward to hearing from you.

 

Want to see how we'd look at your roof?

Start with a SmartMatch™ Needs Analysis, or call (206) 487-4877.

Book a SmartMatch

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the difference between a material warranty and a workmanship warranty?

A material warranty is provided by the manufacturer and covers only the physical products (like shingles) against factory defects. A workmanship warranty is provided by the contractor and covers errors made during the installation process, such as improper nailing or flashing.

2. Does a "Lifetime Warranty" cover the cost of labor to replace a roof?

Not under a standard material defect-only warranty. The maker pays labor only to repair, replace or recover its own defective material. It does not pay for tear-off, disposal, flashings, vents or other components, or for installation workmanship. Under the Owens Corning Standard Product Limited Warranty, that labor applies only during its TRU PROtection period; after that, coverage is prorated, for materials only, with no labor. Only comprehensive or extended warranties typically include broader labor coverage.

3. Why do I need to hire a "certified" contractor for an extended warranty?

Leading manufacturers like CertainTeed and Owens Corning only offer their best, comprehensive warranties to homeowners who use contractors they have specifically vetted and certified to install their products to high standards.

4. What common issues are typically excluded from workmanship warranties?

Most workmanship warranties do not cover "acts of God" (like storm or hail damage), ice damming, damage from foot traffic, or issues caused by alterations made to the roof after the initial installation.

5. How long does a typical metal roof warranty last compared to composition shingles?

While composition shingles often have a material warranty, metal roofs in Seattle typically feature a warranty specifically on the paint/finish, as the metal itself is extremely durable and rarely "fails."

6. What happens to my warranty if my roof isn't ventilated properly?

Improper ventilation is a leading cause of denied claims. If basic installation standards aren't met, manufacturers may label it as "negligence" and void the coverage, which is why proper attic ventilation is a critical code requirement.

7. Can I install a new roof over my existing shingles to save money?

While possible with metal roofing, it is rarely recommended. Doing so can complicate your warranty and hide underlying issues, making a full roof replacement a much safer long-term investment.

8. Are warranties different for flat roofs like TPO or PVC?

Yes. Flat roof warranties often focus on the heat-welded seams. Some extended warranties are only available for commercial projects. You can learn more about these "rooftop bathtubs" in our flat roofing guide.

9. How do I know if a roofing contractor is trustworthy enough to honor their warranty?

You should look for contractors who photo-document their work and have a long-standing reputation. Checking their history and process is essential to ensure they won't go out of business and leave you unprotected.

10. What is the "TripleGuard Warranty" offered by RoofSmart?

The TripleGuard Warranty is a specialized protection plan that provides homeowners in the Seattle area with lifetime workmanship and lifetime material coverage on eligible roofs, plus a promise the work meets code. We stand behind the installation 100%.

Topics:

Products