Want to see how we'd look at your roof?
Start with a SmartMatch™ Needs Analysis, or call (206) 487-4877.
Frequently Asked Questions About Euroshield vs. Premium Cedar Shake
1. Is Euroshield better than cedar shake for Seattle homes?
For many Seattle homeowners, Euroshield may be the more practical option because it offers strong impact resistance, algae resistance, and lower maintenance requirements. Its non-porous rubber construction is also well suited for homeowners concerned about moisture and organic growth.
Premium cedar shake has a major advantage in appearance. If having an authentic natural cedar roof is your highest priority, premium cedar may be worth its higher maintenance requirements.
2. How long does Euroshield roofing last compared to premium cedar shake?
Both Euroshield and premium cedar shake can have an expected lifespan of around 50 years. However, achieving that lifespan with premium cedar depends on the type of cedar and treatment as well as keeping up with the appropriate maintenance.
This means homeowners shouldn't compare the two materials based on lifespan alone. Maintenance requirements and long-term costs should also be considered.
3. How much does Euroshield cost compared to premium cedar shake in Seattle?
Based on the projects discussed in this article, Euroshield can cost approximately $60,000 to $70,000 to install in the Seattle area. Premium cedar shake can range from approximately $60,000 to $100,000.
Premium cedar can become more expensive because the material is shipped from Canada and installation is more labor-intensive. Actual roof replacement costs will depend on the size, complexity, and specific requirements of the roof.
4. Does Euroshield look like real cedar shake?
Euroshield is designed to imitate the appearance of cedar shake, and its appearance can become more weathered as it ages. However, it isn't real wood.
For homeowners primarily concerned about achieving an authentic cedar aesthetic, premium cedar shake has the advantage. Euroshield is better suited to someone who likes the cedar look but places greater emphasis on durability and maintenance.
5. Is Euroshield more impact-resistant than cedar shake?
Yes. Euroshield has a Class 4 impact resistance rating and its rubber construction makes it highly durable against impacts.
The article's project examples demonstrate the difference: a Euroshield roof suffered relatively minor exterior damage when a tree fell on it, while a cedar shake roof involved in a similar incident sustained much more substantial damage. The exact outcome of any storm or falling-tree event will depend on factors such as the size, weight, and location of the impact.
6. Does Euroshield grow algae?
Algae growth is less likely on Euroshield because the roofing material is made from non-porous rubber. While algae growth is still possible, Euroshield is naturally more resistant to it than cedar.
Premium cedar can also resist algae for a period of time when properly protected, but algae can eventually develop on the material.
7. Does Euroshield require less maintenance than cedar shake?
Yes. Euroshield does not require the same type of recurring protective coatings associated with some premium cedar shake roofs. Routine maintenance primarily involves keeping the roof clear of debris and addressing problems if they occur.
Depending on the cedar product and treatment, premium cedar can require significantly more attention and expense over its lifespan. Homeowners considering cedar should understand the maintenance requirements of the specific cedar product they're purchasing rather than treating all cedar shake roofs as the same.
8. What is the difference between CCA-treated and fire-treated cedar shake?
For premium cedar shake, homeowners may have the option of CCA-treated shake or fire-treated shake, but not both on the same product discussed in this article.
For Seattle-area homes, the article recommends considering CCA-treated premium cedar because the treatment helps protect the cedar and reduces the amount of ongoing treatment required. The appropriate option will depend on the home's needs and any applicable roofing requirements.
9. Is Euroshield easier to install than premium cedar shake?
Generally, yes. Both materials require a roofing contractor who understands the specific installation requirements of the product, but premium cedar shake installation is particularly technical and labor-intensive.
Cedar installation requires specialized tools and expertise. That additional labor is one reason a premium cedar shake roof can become more expensive than Euroshield.
10. Who should choose Euroshield instead of premium cedar shake?
Euroshield is likely the better fit for a Seattle homeowner who wants a cedar-like appearance while prioritizing impact resistance, lower maintenance, algae resistance, and long-term value.
Premium cedar shake is better suited to a homeowner whose highest priority is the authentic appearance of natural cedar and who is comfortable with its higher installation and potential maintenance costs. Neither choice is automatically right for every home, the decision ultimately depends on whether you prioritize performance and maintenance or the appearance of real cedar.
Topics: