Best Metal Roofing Contractors in Seattle Compared for 2026
| 📅
23 min read
Looking for a company to put a metal roof on your home can feel like a lot. Metal is a big purchase, and you want the crew that installs it to get it right.
RoofSmart wrote this post, and we're one of the 10 companies in it. We chose the scoring rules, published them below, and scored ourselves the same way as everyone else. Our card shows where we fall short, too.
We respect healthy competition, and we want you to be as informed as possible. You deserve to find the roofing company that will work best for your needs. Even if that means not choosing to work with us.
Every point comes from public records, metal maker and trade group lists, Google, Yelp, BBB and each company's own website. The 60 points shown are the ones anyone can check. The other 40 can only be judged from a bid, so treat this page as a starting point, not a substitute for reading a proposal.
Quick Answers
Seattle Metal Roofing Contractors (2026)
We put 10 metal roof replacement contractors that serve Greater Seattle side by side, including ourselves, scored by one set of published rules. RoofSmart wrote this post and scored itself the same way as everyone else.
Scores on the 60 points anyone can check:
- RoofSmart: 52
- Interlock Metal Roofing: 50
- Three Tree Roofing: 45
- Elite Roofing & Remodel: 43
- Hanley Roofing: 38
- Mountaintop Metal Roofing: 28
- Patriot Roofing: 26
- Guardian Roofing: 14
- State Roofing & Exteriors: 13
- Valentine Roofing: 9
What we checked:
- L&I records
- Years in business
- In-house crews
- Metal credentials
- Published metal spec
- Metal portfolio
- Warranty terms
- 12-month Google and Yelp averages
- BBB complaints, last 3 years
How did we score these metal roofers?
RoofSmart wrote this scorecard and scored itself in it. We chose the rules, published them below, and applied them the same way to all 10 companies, ourselves included.
The checks add up to 60 points anyone can check from public records and company websites. Three more checks, written scope (15), Tailored Solution for Me (10) and cost and value (15), can only be judged from a bid, so none of the 10 was scored on them. Ask for them in your own bids.
Safety and licensing points
| Check | How it's scored |
|---|---|
| L&I safety10 | Inspections that ended with citations from Nov 16, 2021 to Nov 16, 2026, including any under appeal, divided by 5 (or by years licensed if under 5). An inspection counts only if it lists at least one violation. None: 10. Up to 0.25 a year: 8. Over 0.25 to 0.5: 6. Over 0.5 to 1.0: 3. Over 1.0: 0, plus a safety flag. |
| License type1 | General contractor: 1. Specialty license: 0. |
| Strikes, bond suits and lapses4 | Clean record: 4. One open bond suit, or 2 or more lapses of over a month since Nov 16, 2021: 2. Two open suits, or one open suit plus 2 or more such lapses: 1. Any strike or debarment: 0. |
| Years in business5 | Counted from the earliest linked L&I license. Under 5 years: 0. 5 to under 10: 2. 10 to under 15: 4. 15 or more: 5. |
Crews and metal points
| Check | How it's scored |
|---|---|
| In-house crews10 | 10 if the company's own site says installs are done by its own employees or its own company, not subcontractors, AND its L&I workers' comp account shows the roofing class (0507) active with reported workers, AND no L&I citation shows it using subs. Otherwise 0. |
| Metal credentials5 | A metal maker's installer program confirmed in the maker's own list: 3. Metal Roofing Alliance (MRA) contractor membership: 2. Claimed but not in the maker's list: 0, plus a flag. A maker that publishes no list: 0, marked not checkable, no flag. |
| Published metal spec5 | From the company's own metal pages. PVDF or Kynar 500 stated as a finish it installs: 2. Panel gauge stated as a number: 1 (a stated panel thickness in inches counts here, since that's what gauge measures). Panel maker or product line named: 1. A snow retention plan or a named metal underlayment: 1. |
| Metal portfolio5 | Distinct residential metal projects shown with a town named. 10 or more: 5. 3 to 9: 2. Under 3: 0. Photos of one job count once. |
Warranty, review and BBB points
| Check | How it's scored |
|---|---|
| Warranty honesty7 | 7 if the published terms say what is covered and what isn't. 4 if they say what is covered and for how long, but list no exclusions. 0 if no coverage terms can be read. |
| Reviews8 | Reviews posted in the 12 months ending Oct 14, 2026. The score uses the simple average of the Google and Yelp 12-month averages, or one platform alone if the other has none in that window. If neither can be verified, the line scores 0. A company needs at least 10 reviews in the window to earn points. 4.8 or higher: 8. 4.6 to under 4.8: 6. 4.4 to under 4.6: 4. 4.0 to under 4.4: 2. Under 4.0: 0. |
| Total60 | |
Which reviews count: every Google listing and every Yelp listing a company has inside our market, which is King, Pierce, Thurston and Kitsap counties and south Snohomish County (Everett and south). Reviews from all of a company's in-market listings on one platform are pooled, so bigger listings count for more. Listings outside that market, like Stanwood, Bellingham or Oregon, are left out.
Six of these companies are also in our Seattle roofing companies scorecard: RoofSmart, Patriot, Hanley, Guardian, State and Valentine. For RoofSmart, Hanley, Guardian and Valentine, we reused that post's Google and Yelp figures and review points exactly as published. For Patriot and State, we read their current Google and Yelp review lists for the same 12 months, across every in-market listing, and scored them by the same rule. We did the same for Interlock, Three Tree, Elite and Mountaintop.
Live pages and archive copies
Some company websites blocked our reads: Patriot's, State's and Interlock's maker installer list. For those we used archive (Wayback Machine) copies, and each archive read shows its capture date. Everything else was read from the live page and is covered by the last updated date at the top. We didn't call anyone or fill out any forms.
How did the 10 metal roof contractors rank?
RoofSmart is first at 52 and Interlock Metal Roofing is second at 50. Interlock's 0 on reviews comes from a single one-star Yelp review pulling its blend under 4.0, and its card explains it. Elite Roofing & Remodel is fourth at 43, two points behind Three Tree.
| Rank, company, score and note |
|---|
|
1. RoofSmart (Kent)
52/60Reviews 8 of 8; safety 3 of 10
|
|
2. Interlock Metal Roofing (PNW), Stanwood
50/60Reviews 0 of 8: one one-star Yelp review in the window
|
|
3. Three Tree Roofing Company (Kent)
45/60Metal is one of seven materials it installs
|
|
4. Elite Roofing & Remodel (Snohomish)
43/60Metal is a minor line; safety right at the edge
|
|
5. Hanley Construction / Hanley Roofing (Port Orchard)
38/60Little public metal evidence
|
|
6. Mountaintop Metal Roofing (Seattle office)
28/60Reviews 0 of 8: one one-star Yelp review in the window
|
|
7. Patriot Roofing (Gig Harbor)
26/60Site points from archive copies; reviews 0 of 8
|
|
8. Guardian Roofing, Gutters & Insulation (Auburn)
14/60After BBB minus 5; safety flag
|
|
9. State Roofing & Exteriors
13/60After BBB minus 5; 2 open bond suits; reviews 0 of 8
|
|
10. Valentine Roofing (Tukwila)
9/60After BBB minus 5; safety flag; 1 open bond suit
|
How did each company score, line by line?
Each card adds up to the total out of 60, after any BBB deduction. Quotes are from the company's own pages or the public record linked in the same row.
1. RoofSmart (Kent): 52 of 60
We do well on crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty. Our weak spot is safety: 3 L&I inspections with citations in the window, so we score 3 of 10 there.
| L&I safety3 of 10 | 3 inspections with citations: 07/11/2024 Tacoma, 11/08/2024 Edgewood, 10/10/2025 Port Orchard (appealed, final 02/19/2026). That's 0.60 a year. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. L&I record |
| Strikes, suits, lapses4 of 4 | No strikes or debarment. Bond suit 24-2-10877-2 (Pierce) was dismissed 03/12/2026, so no open suit. One lapse, 12/30/2021 to 01/18/2022 (19 days), not over a month. L&I record |
| Years5 of 5 | Earliest linked license ROOFSSI891DB, effective 03/02/2011 (15.7 years). L&I record |
| In-house crews10 of 10 | Our metal page: "Standing seam and stamped metal, both installed by our in-house crew". Our L&I comp account shows roofing class 0507 active, "51 to 75 Workers". No citation mentions subs. Metal page |
| Metal credentials5 of 5 | MRA: "Contractor Member, GOLD" (2). ProVia installer program (3): ProVia's public dealer locator didn't list us in roofing searches at five Washington ZIP codes, so this 3 rests on our own confirmation, not the locator. EDCO and Kassel & Irons: not checkable, no public list. MRA listing, ProVia locator |
| Published metal spec4 of 5 | "Most of our metal roofs get a PVDF paint system, Kynar or Hylar. When budget matters most, we sometimes use SMP instead." (2). 24 and 26 gauge stated (1). ProVia, EDCO and Kassel & Irons named (1). No snow retention plan or named underlayment (0). Metal page |
| Metal portfolio5 of 5 | Gallery titles name 9 towns: Bellevue, Sammamish, Issaquah, Burien, North Bend, Lynnwood, Auburn, Seattle and Renton. Bellevue and Seattle each show two different metal jobs, so at least 11 distinct jobs. Metal gallery |
| Warranty honesty7 of 7 | Our TripleGuard page lists what is and isn't covered, with examples, and has a section titled "What VOIDS a RoofSmart Warranty?". Warranty page |
| Reviews8 of 8 | From our Seattle post, 12 months ending 10/14/2026: Google 4.87, Yelp 5.00, blended 4.93. Small Yelp sample. Seattle post |
| BBBnone | A+, 0 complaints in the last 3 years, as published in our Seattle post. BBB profile |
| Where we fall short: 3 of 10 on safety, no snow retention plan or named underlayment on our metal page, a ProVia credential you can't check on ProVia's public locator, and a small Yelp sample. Our PVDF finish goes on most of our metal roofs, not all of them; a budget bid could be SMP, so ask which finish your bid includes. | |
2. Interlock Metal Roofing (PNW), Stanwood: 50 of 60
Interlock has a clean L&I record, a full metal spec and a big Washington portfolio. Its 0 on reviews comes from one one-star Yelp review: its Seattle Google listing averaged 4.77, and on Google alone it would have scored 6.
Interlock: L&I record and crews
| L&I safety10 of 10 | 0 inspections with citations in the window on either license, INTERMR754O6 or INTERII020LC. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. L&I record |
| Strikes, suits, lapses4 of 4 | No strikes or debarment. One bond suit (21-2-00501-08, Cowlitz) was dismissed 08/09/2022. Only one lapse over a month since 11/16/2021 (65 days in 2023), so the record counts as clean. L&I record, INTERII020LC |
| Years5 of 5 | Earliest linked license INTERSR110RK, effective 12/12/1989. L&I record |
| In-house crews10 of 10 | Site: panels "installed by our own company" and "The company that quotes your roof is the company that installs it". L&I comp account shows 0507 active. Flag: L&I reports only "1 to 3 Workers" for Q3 2026. Home page, About, FAQ |
Interlock: Metal, warranty and reviews
| Metal credentials3 of 5 | Interlock's installer list: "Interlock Metal Roofing (PNW) Inc. Certified Interlock® Installation Center · Washington" (3). The live page blocked our read, so this is from an archive copy captured 2026-09-01. MRA lists only the maker, Interlock Roofing LTD, as a "Manufacturer Member", not this contractor (0). Archive copy, MRA listing |
| Published metal spec5 of 5 | "the Alunar® coating system, a 70% PVDF coating" (2). Panels "at 0.0276 inch" (1). Interlock Roofing named as maker (1). "snow guards planned at the quote" (1). Home page, FAQ |
| Metal portfolio5 of 5 | 28 captioned Washington projects in 21 towns, including Seattle, Redmond, Lynnwood, North Bend, Enumclaw, Fall City, Lakewood and Bremerton. Gallery |
| Warranty honesty7 of 7 | States what the maker's material warranty covers and lists exclusions plainly, including "Does not cover installation workmanship", ice damming, cosmetic hail dents, organic growth, and the transfer fee and deadline. Warranty page, Metal roof warranties |
| Reviews0 of 8 | In-market listings, 12 months ending 10/14/2026. Google, Seattle listing: 26 reviews, average 4.77. Yelp, Seattle listing: 1 review, one star, average 1.00. Blended (4.77 + 1.00) / 2 = 2.88, under 4.0, so 0. That's 27 reviews in the window, so this isn't a too few reviews case. The Stanwood listings are outside our market and left out; adding them back still scores 0. Google, Seattle, Yelp, Seattle |
| BBBnone | A+, 2 complaints in the last 3 years, none in the last 12 months. Two is not over 3, so no deduction. BBB profile |
| Flags: a small comp workforce band (1 to 3 workers) next to a site claim of "3,219 completed roofs in Washington". The site prints its license as INTERMR75406; L&I lists it as INTERMR754O6, with a letter O. | |
3. Three Tree Roofing Company (Kent): 45 of 60
Three Tree has in-house crews, a full published metal spec and metal project pages in 10 towns. Metal is one of seven materials it installs. Its weak spot is safety, at 3 of 10.
Three Tree: L&I record and crews
| L&I safety3 of 10 | 3 inspections with citations: 09/21/2023 Tacoma, 12/16/2024 Issaquah, 05/29/2026 Everett (appealed 10/02/2026, no final order). That's 0.60 a year. Two more inspections in the window listed no violations and aren't counted; counting them gives 1.00 a year, still 3 points. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. L&I record |
| Strikes, suits, lapses4 of 4 | No strikes or debarment, no bond suits. One 1-day lapse in September 2021, before the window. L&I record |
| Years5 of 5 | Earliest linked license THREETR909J9, effective 04/29/2010, shown as a link on its current record (16.5 years). The current license, THREETR832OL, has been effective since 09/18/2017. The site says "more than 15 years". L&I record |
| In-house crews10 of 10 | FAQ: "When a roofing company has its own roofer install crews (not sub-contractors) they have more time to complete the roofing project correctly." Metal page: "Our metal crews are dedicated metal installers and work with metal every day." L&I comp account shows 0507 active, "76 to 100 Workers". No citation mentions subs. FAQ, Metal page |
Three Tree: Metal, warranty and reviews
| Metal credentials0 of 5 | Not in the MRA directory. Nu-Ray is named as the only metal maker it uses, and we couldn't confirm a Nu-Ray installer listing. Its CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster and Malarkey programs are shingle programs. MRA directory, Nu-Ray page |
| Published metal spec5 of 5 | "24 Gauge Kynar with Ocean Guard" and "26 Gauge Kynar 500" (2). "24 and 26 gauge G90 or AZ50 steel" (1). Nu-Ray named, with NRM-1000, 1750, 2000, 5000 and 6000 (1). "an underlayment of 30# (minimum) roofing felt applied horizontally from eave to ridge" (1); that's Nu-Ray's installation text, republished on Three Tree's page. No snow guard plan. Nu-Ray page |
| Metal portfolio5 of 5 | 18 metal project pages; 16 name a town, across 10 towns: Duvall, Bellevue, Redmond, Woodinville, Clyde Hill, Auburn, Seattle, Issaquah, Mercer Island and Burien. Each town is counted once, so at least 10 distinct jobs. Seattle metal roof, Burien metal roof |
| Warranty honesty4 of 7 | "25 year workmanship warranty on all metal roof installs", Nu-Ray "40 year and 50 year warranty options", and "A 40-year non-prorated finish warranty can be supplied". Coverage and length are stated; no exclusions are published, and there's no warranty page. Nu-Ray page |
| Reviews8 of 8 | In-market listings, 12 months ending 10/14/2026. Google, Kent, Seattle and Bellevue listings: 98 reviews, average 4.88. Yelp, Kent listing: 9 reviews, all five stars, 5.00. Blended 4.94. Small Yelp sample. Google, Kent, Google, Seattle, Google, Bellevue, Yelp, Kent |
| BBBnone | A+, no complaints in the last 3 years. BBB profile |
| Flags: an appeal is pending on the 05/29/2026 citation. The 2010 license start has a gap from 2012 to 2017; on the current license alone, Years would be 2 of 5. | |
4. Elite Roofing & Remodel (Snohomish): 43 of 60
"Elite Roofing" is a common name in Washington. This card is Elite Roofing & Remodel LLC of Snohomish and Mill Creek, L&I license ELITERR892CA. It's mainly an asphalt, cedar and PVC roofer, and metal is a minor line. It has in-house crews, a full warranty page and strong recent reviews, but it sits right at the edge on safety.
Elite: L&I record and crews
| L&I safety3 of 10 | 5 inspections with citations: 04/26/2022 Woodinville (appealed, final 08/31/2022), 10/30/2023 Woodinville (appealed, final 03/20/2025), 03/05/2024 Everett (appealed, final 03/20/2025), 01/23/2026 Snoqualmie (appealed 06/23/2026, no final order), 07/07/2026 Arlington (appealed 08/03/2026, no final order). That's 1.00 a year, which isn't over 1.0, so 3. One more would score 0. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. L&I record |
| Strikes, suits, lapses4 of 4 | No strikes or debarment, no bond suits. One 1-day lapse in 2018, before the window. Three electrical infractions issued 05/11/2023, now satisfied, $1,500 in total, aren't strikes under this rule. L&I record |
| Years5 of 5 | Earliest linked license PCCONC*943ND ("PC Contracting", same UBI), effective 08/04/2006. ELITERR892CA has been effective since 02/01/2011. The site says "over 25 years"; L&I and BBB give a 2006 start. L&I record |
| In-house crews10 of 10 | An FAQ says the company is "employing skilled professionals for every project". Its L&I workers' comp account, 28955000, is in the name of Power Clean Exterior Care LLC, doing business as Elite Roofing & Remodel. It shows roofing class 0507 active, "76 to 100 Workers" for the third quarter of 2026, and the account is current. No citation mentions subs. FAQs, L&I record |
Elite: Metal, warranty and reviews
| Metal credentials0 of 5 | Not in the MRA directory. The site lists GAF, CertainTeed and CSSB shingle installer programs only. Nu-Ray is named, and we couldn't confirm a Nu-Ray installer listing. MRA directory, Warranty page |
| Published metal spec3 of 5 | Nu-Ray page: panels "offer tight weatherproofing and ULTRA-Cool, Kynar-coated finishes" (2). Nu-Ray named, with NRM-1000, 1750, 2000, 5000 and 6000 (1). No gauge number (0). No snow plan or named metal underlayment; the metal page says only "Underlayment and insulation reduce sound transfer" (0). Nu-Ray page, Metal page |
| Metal portfolio2 of 5 | The metal page shows 9 photos whose file names give a town: Snohomish, Clyde Hill, Bellevue (two jobs, different products), Fall City, Mercer Island, Seattle, Woodinville and Granite Falls. That's 9 distinct jobs, and 3 to 9 scores 2. The towns are in the image file names only, not in visible captions, and the project gallery shows no metal. Metal page, Portfolio |
| Warranty honesty7 of 7 | "a 20 year workmanship warranty that is completely transferable", covering failure from improper installation. Not covered: "Structural or cosmetic damage to your home due to roofing system failure is typically not covered", except up to $1,000 in the first two years. Work by others, like skylights, cleaning or an antenna, can void it. No metal warranty terms are published. Warranty page |
| Reviews8 of 8 | In-market listings, 12 months ending 10/14/2026. Google, Snohomish listing: 181 reviews, average 4.85. Yelp, Snohomish listing: 38 reviews, average 4.87. Blended 4.86. Google, Snohomish, Yelp, Snohomish |
| BBBnone | A+, no complaints in the last 3 years. BBB profile |
| Flags: exactly 1.00 inspections with citations a year, so safety is borderline. Three electrical infractions in 2023 (electrical work without a certificate, offering electrical work without an electrical contractor license, and covering work before inspection), all satisfied. The comp account is under a different legal name. "Over 25 years" doesn't match the 2006 license start. | |
5. Hanley Construction / Hanley Roofing (Port Orchard): 38 of 60
Hanley has a long, clean license record and in-house crews, but very little public metal evidence. It scored 0 on metal credentials, metal spec and metal portfolio.
| L&I safety6 of 10 | 2 inspections with citations: 12/04/2023 Bainbridge Island (appealed, final 04/01/2024) and 07/07/2025 Poulsbo. That's 0.40 a year. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. |
| Strikes, suits, lapses4 of 4 | No strikes, no bond suits, no lapses since 11/16/2021. |
| Years5 of 5 | Earliest linked license HANLEC*122BH, effective 01/08/1988. |
| In-house crews10 of 10 | About page: "All our staff work in-house and are not subcontracted, unless previously agreed upon in your contract." L&I comp account shows 0507 active, "51 to 75 Workers". About page |
| Metal credentials0 of 5 | Not in the MRA directory. Its certifications page lists shingle, synthetic and composite programs only, no metal program. MRA directory, Certifications |
| Published metal spec0 of 5 | Metal is named as a material only. No finish, gauge, maker, snow or underlayment spec. Residential roofing |
| Metal portfolio0 of 5 | The project gallery text shows no metal project. Project gallery |
| Warranty honesty4 of 7 | "Lifetime Hanley Warranty" and "layered warranties in writing". Coverage and length are stated; no exclusions are published. Home page |
| Reviews8 of 8 | From our Seattle post, 12 months ending 10/14/2026: Google 4.94, no Yelp reviews in that post's window, so Google alone. Seattle post |
| BBBnone | A+, 0 complaints in the last 3 years, as published in our Seattle post. BBB profile |
| Note: our Seattle post scored Hanley 0 of 10 on in-house crews. For this scorecard we read Hanley's about page, quoted above, so it gets 10 here. | |
6. Mountaintop Metal Roofing (Seattle office): 28 of 60
Mountaintop is a metal roofing company with a big portfolio and five-star recent Google reviews. It loses points on years licensed, on crews, because its Washington comp account shows no roofing class, and on reviews, where one one-star Yelp review pulls its blend under 4.0.
| L&I safety8 of 10 | License MOUNTMR814LR, effective 06/19/2019. 1 inspection with citations: 06/25/2025 Kingston (3 serious items, fall protection). That's 0.20 a year. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. |
| Strikes, suits, lapses4 of 4 | No strikes, no bond suits. A 28-day lapse in 2022 wasn't over a month. A longer bond lapse began before the window; even counted, it's one lapse, so the score doesn't change. |
| Years2 of 5 | Earliest linked license is MOUNTMR814LR, 06/19/2019 (7.4 years). Its L&I address is Vancouver, WA. |
| In-house crews0 of 10 | The comp account shows no roofing class, only building material dealers and clerical, "4 to 6 Workers". The site mentions "our crews" and a "lead installer" but doesn't say installers are its own employees. About page |
| Metal credentials2 of 5 | MRA "Contractor Member, Gold" at a Seattle address (2). Classic Metal Roofing Systems products named on its site: not checkable, no public list. MRA listing |
| Published metal spec2 of 5 | Oxford shingle: "heavy .024 inch thick" aluminum (1). Classic Metal Roofing Systems named (1). No PVDF or Kynar named, only "superior coatings" (0). No named underlayment or snow plan (0). Oxford shingle, Standing seam |
| Metal portfolio5 of 5 | "Our Work" links 27 distinct job pages; 14 name distinct Washington towns, including Bellevue, Sammamish, Mercer Island, Newcastle, Maple Valley, Bothell, Snohomish and Steilacoom. Our Work |
| Warranty honesty4 of 7 | Lists highlights: lifetime, non prorated, transferable, 120 to 165 mph wind, chalk and fade coverage. No exclusions; "For full warranty details contact Mountaintop Metal Roofing." Warranty page |
| Reviews0 of 8 | In-market listings, 12 months ending 10/14/2026. Google, Seattle, Tacoma and Bellevue listings: 22 reviews, all five stars, 5.00. Yelp, Seattle listing: 1 review, one star, 1.00; its Tacoma and Bellevue Yelp listings have no reviews. Blended (5.00 + 1.00) / 2 = 3.00, under 4.0, so 0. On Google alone it would score 8. Google, Seattle, Google, Tacoma, Google, Bellevue, Yelp, Seattle |
| BBBnone | A+, no complaints in the last 3 years on the Tigard, OR profile, which lists its Tacoma and Bellevue offices. Its Bellingham, WA profile also shows none. BBB, Tigard, BBB, Bellingham |
| Flag: no roofing risk class on its Washington comp account, while its 2025 citation describes its employees doing roofing work. | |
7. Patriot Roofing (Gig Harbor): 26 of 60
Patriot's live site blocked our reads, so its site points come from archive copies, with capture dates shown. We found no metal page, so it scored low on the metal checks. Its one Yelp review in the window, a three-star review, pulls its review blend under 4.0.
| L&I safety6 of 10 | 2 inspections with citations: 11/21/2024 Gig Harbor and 10/03/2025 Bremerton (appealed, final 10/08/2026). That's 0.40 a year. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. |
| Strikes, suits, lapses4 of 4 | No strikes, no bond suits. One 1-day lapse on 01/13/2022. |
| Years4 of 5 | PATRIRL884BL, effective 01/13/2012 (14.8 years). An older linked fence license isn't counted. |
| In-house crews10 of 10 | About page: "We employ factory-trained and highly qualified remodelers" (archive capture 2026-06-07). L&I comp account shows 0507 active, "76 to 100 Workers". Archive copy |
| Metal credentials0 of 5 | Not in the MRA directory. CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster is a shingle program. SoundLoc named: not checkable. MRA directory |
| Published metal spec1 of 5 | Options page names "SoundLoc Roofing" metal systems (1). No finish, gauge, snow or underlayment (archive capture 2026-06-07). Archive copy |
| Metal portfolio0 of 5 | The gallery has no metal project text (archive capture 2026-05-21). Archive copy |
| Warranty honesty0 of 7 | No warranty page capture exists, and the roofing page FAQ "What is the warranty on a new roof?" has no answer text in the archive copy (capture 2026-05-21). No terms could be read. Archive copy |
| Reviews0 of 8 | In-market listing, 12 months ending 10/14/2026. Google, Gig Harbor listing: 39 reviews, average 4.56. Yelp, Gig Harbor listing: 1 review, dated 04/08/2026, three stars, average 3.00. Blended (4.56 + 3.00) / 2 = 3.78, under 4.0, so 0. On Google alone it would score 4. Google, Gig Harbor, Yelp, Gig Harbor |
| BBBnone | A+, 1 complaint in the last 3 years, as published in our Seattle post. BBB profile |
| Note: our Seattle post gave Patriot 4 of 7 on warranty. For this scorecard, no warranty terms could be read, live or archived, so it's 0. | |
8. Guardian Roofing, Gutters & Insulation (Auburn): 14 of 60 after BBB minus 5
Guardian is an MRA member and names a Kynar finish, but it carries a safety flag, scores 0 on crews and lost 5 points for BBB complaints.
| L&I safety0 of 10, safety flag | 6 inspections with citations: 04/06/2022 Seattle, 08/30/2023 Tacoma, 11/02/2023 Lynnwood, 07/17/2025 Tacoma, 08/20/2025 Lacey (under appeal), 03/10/2026 Kent. That's 1.20 a year. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. |
| Strikes, suits, lapses4 of 4 | No strikes. Two bond suits, both dismissed, so no open suit. No lapses listed. |
| Years5 of 5 | Earliest linked license GUARDRL942NN, 08/15/2006. |
| In-house crews0 of 10 | The L&I comp account shows 0507 active, "Greater than 100 Workers". But none of the pages we read (home, about, careers, metal pages and a blog post) says installs are done by its own employees rather than subs; they say "trained crews". Metal roofing page |
| Metal credentials2 of 5 | MRA "Contractor Member" (2). Isaiah / Classic: not checkable. Nu-Ray is named, and we couldn't confirm a Nu-Ray installer listing. MRA listing |
| Published metal spec3 of 5 | Nu-Ray page: "Kynar 500® and silicone-modified polyester coatings" (2). Nu-Ray NRM profiles and Isaiah named (1). "multiple gauges", no number (0). Underlayment generic (0). Nu-Ray page |
| Metal portfolio0 of 5 | Metal posts show at most 2 jobs with a town, both "Seattle", possibly the same job. The projects page isn't metal specific. Projects |
| Warranty honesty4 of 7 | A 1 year 100% satisfaction guarantee, 3 years with the paid protection plan, and a named workmanship warranty. Exclusions appear only in general terms in a blog post ("may not cover"). Protection plan, Warranty post |
| Reviews0 of 8 | From our Seattle post, 12 months ending 10/14/2026: Google 4.81, Yelp 3.00, blended 3.90, under 4.0. Seattle post |
| BBBminus 5 | A+, 7 complaints in the last 3 years, as published in our Seattle post. BBB profile |
| Note: our Seattle post scores Guardian's crews as a mix of its own crews and others. This scorecard scores crews 10 or 0, and we found no in-house install statement on the pages we read, so it's 0 here. | |
9. State Roofing & Exteriors: 13 of 60 after BBB minus 5
State's live site also blocked our reads, so its site points come from archive copies. It names a Kynar finish and a panel maker, but it has 2 open bond suits, scored 0 on reviews and lost 5 points for BBB complaints.
| L&I safety8 of 10 | 1 inspection with citations: 08/21/2026 Snohomish, under appeal. That's 0.20 a year. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General. |
| Strikes, suits, lapses1 of 4 | No strikes. 2 open bond suits, both in Thurston County: 24-2-02815-34 (filed 08/13/2024) and 25-2-03163-34 (filed 09/15/2025). No lapses since 2017. |
| Years5 of 5 | Earliest linked license STATERI194R3, 12/23/1981. |
| In-house crews0 of 10 | Archived pages say "Factory-trained crews" and "licensed crews", but don't say installers are employees and not subs (archive capture 2026-06-13). L&I comp account shows 0507 active, "51 to 75 Workers". Archive copy |
| Metal credentials0 of 5 | Not in the MRA directory. Nu-Ray is named, and we couldn't confirm a Nu-Ray installer listing. MRA directory |
| Published metal spec3 of 5 | Standing seam page: "Kynar 500® and SMP coatings" (2). Nu-Ray NRM-1000, 2000 and 5000 named (1). No gauge number, no snow or underlayment spec (archive capture 2026-04-21). Archive copy |
| Metal portfolio0 of 5 | No metal project with a town in the archived pages we read. Its gallery and project pages couldn't be checked, because the archive lookup timed out. |
| Warranty honesty0 of 7 | The archived warranty page covers manufacturer warranties in general terms only (capture 2026-07-16). The home page says "Lifetime workmanship warranties options available" with no terms (capture 2026-08-12). Warranty page copy, Home page copy |
| Reviews0 of 8 | In-market listings, 12 months ending 10/14/2026. Google, Tacoma and Seattle listings: 109 reviews, average 4.39. Yelp, Tacoma and Seattle listings: 4 reviews, average 2.25. Blended (4.39 + 2.25) / 2 = 3.32, under 4.0, so 0. Its Marysville Google listing is outside our market and left out; adding it back still scores 0. Small Yelp sample. Google, Tacoma, Google, Seattle, Yelp, Tacoma, Yelp, Seattle |
| BBBminus 5 | A+, 8 complaints in the last 3 years, as published in our Seattle post. |
| Flag: 2 open bond suits. | |
10. Valentine Roofing (Tukwila): 9 of 60 after BBB minus 5
Valentine's L&I points combine two licenses: the current VALENRL781RW and the older linked VALENRI927J8. Both Valentine workers' comp accounts read "Account is closed. Firm has no active industrial insurance account."
| L&I safety0 of 10, safety flag | 14 inspections with citations in the window: 13 on VALENRL781RW (03/24/2023 to 02/28/2025) and 1 on VALENRI927J8 (12/30/2021 Lake Tapps). That's 2.80 a year. L&I record |
| License type1 of 1 | Construction contractor, General (both). |
| Strikes, suits, lapses1 of 4 | No strikes. 1 open bond suit on VALENRI927J8: 22-2-05424-2 (Pierce), filed 04/04/2022. Two lapses of over a month on that license (04/24/2023 and 04/28/2024), neither reinstated. One open suit plus 2 such lapses scores 1. L&I record, VALENRI927J8 |
| Years5 of 5 | Earliest linked license VALENRI927J8, 04/28/2008. |
| In-house crews0 of 10 | Neither Valentine comp account is active, so there's no active roofing class, and we found no in-house statement on the pages we read. About |
| Metal credentials0 of 5 | Not in the MRA directory. Nu-Ray is named only in a 2017 blog post: not checkable. MRA directory |
| Published metal spec1 of 5 | Metal page: "available in 24 and 26-gauge options" (1). No paint system, no maker on the metal page, no snow or underlayment spec. Metal page |
| Metal portfolio2 of 5 | Metal project posts name 7 towns: Redmond, Lynnwood, Bainbridge Island, Mountlake Terrace, Seattle, Vashon Island and Renton. All are dated 2017 to 2019. Blog |
| Warranty honesty4 of 7 | "Extra Mile Warranty": lifetime of the product installed, any workmanship defect that causes a leak, and up to $500 for interior paint and drywall. Coverage is stated; no exclusions are published. Warranty page |
| Reviews0 of 8 | From our Seattle post, 12 months ending 10/14/2026: Google 4.77, Yelp 2.36, blended 3.57, under 4.0. Seattle post |
| BBBminus 5 | A+, 6 complaints in the last 3 years, as published in our Seattle post. BBB profile |
| Flags: safety over 1 a year, 1 open bond suit, and no active workers' comp account under either Valentine license. | |
What does each company's BBB record show?
BBB counts affect a score only one way: more than 3 complaints in the last 3 years takes off 5 points. Complaint counts are still worth a look before you sign.
For the six companies also in our Seattle post, we used that post's BBB counts, read on October 23, 2026. Interlock, Three Tree, Elite and Mountaintop weren't in that post, so we read their counts from BBB directly.
| Company | Score effect | BBB rating | Complaints, last 3 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. RoofSmart | none | A+ | 0 |
| 2. Interlock Metal Roofing | none | A+ | 2 (none in the last 12 months) |
| 3. Three Tree Roofing | none | A+ | 0 |
| 4. Elite Roofing & Remodel | none | A+ | 0 |
| 5. Hanley Roofing | none | A+ | 0 |
| 6. Mountaintop Metal Roofing | none | A+ | 0 (both profiles) |
| 7. Patriot Roofing | none | A+ | 1 |
| 8. Guardian Roofing | minus 5 | A+ | 7 |
| 9. State Roofing & Exteriors | minus 5 | A+ | 8 |
| 10. Valentine Roofing | minus 5 | A+ | 6 |
All 10 are rated A+. Mountaintop has two BBB profiles, one in Tigard, OR and one in Bellingham, WA, and neither shows a complaint.
Where do these scores come from?
Points came only from public records, public lists and each company's own website. Live reads are covered by the last updated date at the top; archive copies show their capture date.
State records and trade lists
| Source | What it gave us Link |
|---|---|
| WA L&I contractor lookup | Safety, license type, strikes, bond suits, lapses, years licensed, and workers' comp classes and workforce size RoofSmart, Interlock, Interlock, second license, Three Tree, Hanley, Elite, Patriot, Mountaintop, State, Guardian, Valentine, Valentine, older license |
| Metal Roofing Alliance directory | MRA contractor membership Member directory, RoofSmart, Mountaintop, Guardian, Interlock Roofing LTD |
| Metal maker installer lists | Installer programs Interlock installers, Washington (archive capture 2026-09-01), ProVia dealer locator |
Review sites and our Seattle post
| Source | What it gave us Link |
|---|---|
| Our Seattle roofing companies scorecard | Google and Yelp review figures and points for RoofSmart, Hanley, Guardian and Valentine, and BBB counts (read Oct 23, 2026) for those four plus Patriot and State Seattle scorecard |
| Google Maps | Review lists for the in-market listings of Interlock, Three Tree, Elite, Mountaintop, Patriot and State, counted for the 12 months ending Oct 14, 2026 Interlock, Seattle, Three Tree, Kent, Three Tree, Seattle, Three Tree, Bellevue, Elite, Snohomish, Mountaintop, Seattle, Mountaintop, Tacoma, Mountaintop, Bellevue, Patriot, Gig Harbor, State, Tacoma, State, Seattle |
| Yelp | Review lists for the same six companies, same window Interlock, Seattle, Three Tree, Kent, Elite, Snohomish, Mountaintop, Seattle, Patriot, Gig Harbor, State, Tacoma, State, Seattle |
| This row shows where the BBB ratings and complaint counts came from. | |
| BBB | Ratings and complaint counts for Interlock, Three Tree, Elite and Mountaintop, and profile links for the others RoofSmart, Interlock, Three Tree, Hanley, Elite, Patriot, Mountaintop, Tigard, Mountaintop, Bellingham, Guardian, Valentine |
Company websites
| Source | What it gave us Link |
|---|---|
| RoofSmart website | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty Metal roofing, Metal gallery, TripleGuard warranty |
| Interlock website | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty Home, About, FAQ, Gallery, Warranty, Metal roof warranties |
| Three Tree website | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty Metal roof, Nu-Ray metal roofing, Roofing FAQs, Project list |
| Hanley website | Crews, certifications, metal spec, portfolio and warranty Home, About, Certifications, Residential roofing, FAQs, Project gallery |
| Elite website | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty Metal roofing, Nu-Ray metals, Warranty, FAQs, About, Portfolio |
| Mountaintop website | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty About, Our Work, Oxford shingle, Textured shingle, Standing seam, Installation, Warranty |
| Guardian website | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty Metal roofing, Nu-Ray, Classic metal roofing, Projects, Protection plan, Warranty post |
| Valentine website | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty Metal roofing, Warranty, Home, About, Blog |
| Patriot and State were read from archive copies, and each link shows its capture date. | |
| Patriot website, archive copies | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty About (capture 2026-06-07), Options and materials (capture 2026-06-07), Gallery (capture 2026-05-21), Roofing (capture 2026-05-21) |
| State website, archive copies | Crews, metal spec, portfolio and warranty Roofing (capture 2026-06-13), Standing seam (capture 2026-04-21), Metal shake (capture 2026-05-20), Roof types (capture 2026-06-10), Home (capture 2026-08-12), Warranty (capture 2026-07-16) |
Want to see how we'd look at your roof?
Start with a SmartMatch™ Needs Analysis, or call (206) 487-4877.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who made this metal roofer scorecard?
RoofSmart wrote this post, and RoofSmart is one of the 10 companies scored. We chose the rules, published them in this post, and applied them the same way to every company, ourselves included.
Why did Interlock get 0 of 8 for reviews?
Interlock had 27 reviews in the 12 months ending Oct 14, 2026, enough to score. Its Seattle Google listing averaged 4.77, but its Seattle Yelp listing had one review in that window, a one-star review. We average the two platforms, so the blend is 2.88, under the 4.0 needed for points.
Why do Guardian and Valentine get 0 for crews?
Neither site says installs are done by the company's own employees rather than subs. Guardian's pages say "trained crews", though its comp account shows the roofing class active. Both Valentine comp accounts are closed, so there's no active roofing class.
What do the 60 points cover?
Labor and Industries safety 10, license type 1, strikes, bond suits and lapses 4, years 5, in-house crews 10, metal credentials 5, published metal spec 5, metal portfolio 5, warranty honesty 7 and reviews 8. Written scope, a tailored solution and cost and value can only be judged from a bid.
Which Google and Yelp reviews count?
Reviews from the 12 months ending Oct 14, 2026, on every listing a company has in King, Pierce, Thurston, Kitsap or south Snohomish County. For RoofSmart, Hanley, Guardian and Valentine, we reused our Seattle post's published figures.
How do BBB complaints change a score?
A company with more than 3 BBB complaints in the last 3 years loses 5 points. State, Guardian and Valentine each lost 5. Interlock has 2 and Patriot has 1, so neither lost points.
What counts as a published metal spec?
It has to be on the company's own metal pages. A PVDF or Kynar 500 finish it installs is worth 2. A panel gauge, a named panel maker, and a snow retention plan or named metal underlayment are worth 1 each.
Why were some sites scored from archive copies?
Patriot's and State's live sites blocked our reads, and so did Interlock's maker installer list. For those we used Wayback Machine copies, and each card shows the capture date for those reads.
Topics: